Is it true that asbestos cement shingles should be removed from homes?

The assertion that asbestos cement shingles should be removed from homes is not universally true; it is context-dependent. It is essential to evaluate the condition of the shingles first. If they are intact and not releasing harmful fibers, they may not pose an immediate risk. Asbestos becomes hazardous when it is disturbed, damaged, or deteriorates, leading to fiber release. Therefore, the most accurate response is that it depends on the condition of the shingles.

In cases where the shingles are in good shape, leaving them in place might be the safest option because removal can disturb them and potentially release asbestos fibers into the air, posing health risks. Regular inspections and monitoring for any signs of wear, damage, or deterioration should be conducted to determine if action is necessary. In some localities, regulations may also guide whether removal is required based on condition, reinforcing that context is key in such decisions.